Performance reviews are meant to help employees grow, recognize their hard work, and align their efforts with company goals. But let’s be honest—they don’t always work that way.
Many employees dread reviews because they can feel unfair, overly critical, or disconnected from reality. Sometimes, bias creeps in, and people feel judged for the wrong reasons. Instead of boosting confidence, reviews can leave people frustrated or overlooked.
So, how do we fix this? How do we make performance reviews fair, supportive, and helpful for everyone? It’s not about getting rid of reviews entirely but more about improving the process.
Why Traditional Performance Reviews Are Failing Today’s Workforce
The traditional way of doing performance reviews is pretty simple: once a year, a manager sits down with an employee and talks about how well (or not so well) they’ve done over the past 12 months. It’s often a formal meeting where the manager points out what went right and wrong and then gives a score or rating. That score is usually tied to raises, bonuses, or promotions.
Unfortunately, these reviews are often too vague, too focused on the past, and not very helpful for employees who want to know how to improve or grow.
The annual performance review system doesn’t work well anymore because work happens much faster these days. Things change constantly—new projects, shifting priorities, and unexpected challenges come up all the time. Waiting a whole year to discuss employee performance is like trying to fix a problem after it’s already too late.
Another significant issue is fairness. Managers might base their reviews on their most recent memory or personal opinions, which can leave out the full picture of someone’s work. Quieter employees or those who aren’t as “visible” can be overlooked, even if they’re doing a great job.
How Do We Make Performance Reviews Fair in the Workplace?
Here are simple and practical ways to help you improve performance reviews and make them more effective:
1. Use Clear and Fair Standards to Measure Performance
The biggest problem with traditional performance evaluations is often the lack of clear standards. When managers rely on vague feedback, it opens the door to personal opinions, bias, and confusion. For example, being told, “You need to improve teamwork,” doesn’t help much because it’s unclear what that means or how to fix it.
Instead, reviews should focus on measurable goals. For example, a better way to set expectations might be to “Complete two projects with teams from other departments this quarter.” Clear goals like this leave no room for confusion. Employees know exactly what’s expected, and managers have something concrete to measure performance.
Using a simple scoring system, or a “rubric,” also helps. Everyone is judged by the same standards, which makes the process fairer. When employees know the rules and expectations upfront, they feel more confident that they’re being treated fairly.
2. Be Aware of Bias and Work to Reduce It
Even the most well-meaning managers can let bias influence their decisions without realizing it. Bias happens when people judge others based on personal beliefs or stereotypes instead of performance. For example, studies show that women often get feedback about their personalities (like “she lacks confidence”) instead of their work skills, while men get credit for things like “leadership.”¹
To fix this, managers need training to spot and reduce bias. Feedback should always be tied to the employee’s work—not their personality or assumptions about who they are. Instead of saying, “You should be friendlier in meetings,” a manager might say, “I’d love to see you ask more questions during team discussions to show your ideas.”
You can also check for patterns in performance evaluations. Are certain groups — like women, people of color, or employees with disabilities — consistently getting lower ratings? If so, there’s likely a fairness problem that needs to be addressed.
When employees feel that bias is being actively tackled, they’re more likely to trust the performance review process and believe it’s fair.
Read more: Awareness and Action: How to Recognize and Reduce Conscious and Unconscious Bias in Interviewing
3. Give Regular Feedback
One of the most significant issues with traditional reviews is timing. Most companies only do reviews once a year, which isn’t very helpful. When employees get feedback, months have passed, and the advice feels outdated. Imagine trying to fix a mistake you made six months ago — it just doesn’t work.
Instead, feedback should happen regularly. Managers can check in with employees weekly, monthly, or even quarterly. These conversations don’t need to be long or formal; they’re a chance to talk about progress, challenges, and achievements in real-time.
For example, if an employee is struggling with a project, a monthly check-in can help the manager step in and offer support. This way, problems get solved quickly, and employees don’t feel left alone. Continuous feedback also allows managers to celebrate small wins along the way, which helps boost confidence.
When performance appraisals are part of an ongoing conversation, they feel more helpful and less stressful.
Read more: Feedback Matters: The Benefits of Giving and Receiving Feedback at Work
4. Get Feedback from More Than One Person
Traditional performance evaluations usually depend on one manager’s opinion. But one person can’t see everything an employee does, which makes this approach limited and sometimes unfair. This is why it’s helpful to include feedback from multiple people—like coworkers, team members, or clients—through “360-degree feedback.”
For example, a manager might not know how well someone collaborates with others, but their teammates or project partners do. Combining different perspectives gives a more complete picture of an employee’s work.
To make this work well, feedback should be anonymous. When people know their comments are private, they’re more likely to be honest and constructive. Employees also feel that the feedback more accurately reflects their work, not just one person’s opinion.
5. Recognize Employees’ Unique Needs
Every employee is different, so performance reviews need to reflect that. Some people work remotely, others have disabilities, and some may prefer written feedback over verbal conversations. Ignoring these differences can make the process feel unfair or unhelpful.
For example, an employee with a disability might need extra time to prepare for a review or require materials in an accessible format. Similarly, remote workers might contribute a lot, but their efforts could go unnoticed because they aren’t physically in the office. Managers must be mindful of these differences and evaluate people based on their results, not where or how they work.
Making minor adjustments like these ensures that every employee has an equal chance to succeed and feel valued during the performance review process.
6. Focus on Growth, Not Just Mistakes
Performance reviews should be about helping employees grow, not just pointing out what they did wrong. If reviews only focus on problems, employees leave feeling demotivated or stuck. Instead, reviews should recognize what employees are doing well while offering support for improvement.
For example, instead of saying, “Your communication needs work,” a manager might say, “I noticed you have great ideas. Let’s work on presenting them more confidently in meetings—I can help you with a training program.” This kind of constructive feedback highlights strengths while providing clear advice for growth.
Working together to set goals for the future also makes performance reviews more productive. If an employee wants to develop new skills or take on more significant responsibilities, the review is a perfect time to discuss those plans and outline the next steps.
When employees see that reviews are about their progress and future career development, they feel motivated to do their best.
Read more: Preparing for Year-End Reviews: Best Practices for Employees with Disabilities and Their Managers
Hire great talent and make your workplace more inclusive with Galt!
At Galt, we specialize in helping businesses hire talented individuals with disabilities who bring fresh ideas, strong skills, and a dedication to success. We simplify the process, allowing you to fill your open roles with hardworking, capable employees while improving diversity in your workplace.
By focusing on inclusive hiring, you’re laying the groundwork for fairer performance reviews and creating an environment where every employee can do their best work. If you have vacancies to fill, feel free to reach out to our team to list them.
To support your efforts further, we’ve created a comprehensive guide to disability inclusive hiring practices in the workplace. This easy-to-follow resource is perfect for business owners, managers, and team leaders looking for practical ways to build a truly inclusive workplace. Download the guide today to learn how to create a supportive environment and set your employees up for success.
References
1. Doldor, Elena. “Research: Men Get More Actionable Feedback Than Women.” Harvard Business Review, 10 Feb. 2021, hbr.org/2021/02/research-men-get-more-actionable-feedback-than-women.
